'They Died Horrible, Violent Deaths': Andrea Yates Drowned Her 5 Kids but Beat Murder Rap (FPD CASE VAULT)
![Andrea Yates: She-Devil Drowned Her Kids but Beat the Rap for Murder](https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/480x251/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 480w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/640x335/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 640w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/768x402/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 768w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/1024x536/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 1024w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/1280x670/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 1280w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/1440x753/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 1440w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/1600x837/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 1600w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/oVsvbjTtV/2160x1130/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-1693257909998.jpg 2160w)
Andrea Yates walks into the courtroom for a hearing Thursday, July 27, 2006, in Houston, where she was committed to the maximum-security North Texas State Hospital in Vernon, Texas.
Apr. 10 2024, Published 10:03 a.m. ET
Andrea Yates horrified the nation as news emerged she ruthlessly killed her five young children.
In the throes of postpartum depression, Yates locked the doors to her house and methodically drowned her kids, 6-month-old Mary, Luke, 2, Paul, 3, John, 5, and Noah, 7, one by one in the bathtub while husband Rusty was at work at NASA's Johnson Space Center.
"The children fought for their lives," said the case's lead prosecutor Kaylynn Williford, "but they died horrible, violent deaths."
SATAN CONTROLLED HER
![Andrea Yates: She-Devil Drowned Her Kids but Beat the Rap for Murder](https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/480x252/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 480w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/640x335/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 640w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/768x402/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 768w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/1024x536/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 1024w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/1280x670/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 1280w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/1440x754/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 1440w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/1600x838/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 1600w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/EsxKMsNwk/2160x1131/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder-2-1693258211067.jpg 2160w)
The family portrait of Yates, her hubby Rusty and their kids (left to right) John, Luke, Paul and Noah hid the lurking horror. Baby Mary (right) was also killed.
When cops arrived at the Clean Lake, Texas, home, they found the four youngest children laid out on a bed. Noah, meanwhile, was still in the bathtub, floating face down.
The bookish-looking Yates claimed Satan controlled her when she held her children's heads under nine inches of water as they struggled.
- 'Beloved Mother, Friend, Daughter' Sonya Massey Shot Dead by Officer After She Phoned 911 for Help: 'Justice at Stake,' Warns Pres. Biden
- Tennessee Pre-Teen Girl Accused of Fatally Suffocating 8-Year-Old Cousin After Fight Over iPhone
- He Got into a Fight at a Wisconsin Bar After Things 'Popped Off.' When He Opened Fire Outside, 3 People Died.
She told a prison psychiatrist: "My children weren't righteous. They were doomed to perish in the fires of hell."
During her sensational trial in 2002, Yates pleaded innocent by reason of insanity. The jury rejected the defense and found her guilty of first-degree murder. Yates was sentenced to life in prison with eligibility for parole in 40 years.
Never miss a story — sign up for the Front Page Detectives newsletter. Be on the scene the moment news breaks.
![Andrea Yates: She-Devil Drowned Her Kids but Beat the Rap for Murder](https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/480x252/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 480w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/640x335/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 640w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/768x402/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 768w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/1024x536/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 1024w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/1280x670/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 1280w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/1440x754/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 1440w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/1600x838/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 1600w, https://media.frontpagedetectives.com/brand-img/0VNk-9d9w/2160x1131/andrea-yates-she-devil-drowned-her-kids-but-beat-the-rap-for-murder3-1693258221751.jpg 2160w)
Haunted hubby Rusty Yates wandered through his dead children's toys at his Texas home (left). After divorcing Andrea, he wed Laura Arnold (right) in 2006.
But a Texas Court of Appeals overturned the conviction in January 2005 on the basis of "erroneous testimony" and ordered a second trial. That trial ended shockingly in a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. She was committed to North Texas State Hospital, a high security mental health facility.
In 2007, the now 59-year-old was moved to a lower level security state mental hospital, where she currently resides. Rusty divorced her and remarried in 2006.
Become a Front Page Detective
Sign up to receive breaking
Front Page Detectives
news and exclusive investigations.