Following a four-day trial, a jury in Williamsburg convicted John Phillip Meadows, 60, of the charges and recommended he be ordered to serve life plus five years when he is sentenced in March, according to the Times-Tribune.
The publication reported the victim in the case, Donna G. Lay, was last seen alive on Jan. 7, 2021. Just over three weeks later, on Feb. 1, police searched Meadow’s property and found the woman’s remains stuffed in an outdoor trash can that was placed behind a door.
At trial, Meadow’s public defender, Clifford Wilson, claimed the victim was domineering and pulled a gun on Meadows after she accused him of cheating on her.
- Convicted Killer Shot His Ex-Girlfriend, Dumped Her Body Stuffed in Toolbox at His Grandmother’s Abandoned Tennessee Home
- He said he tried to wrestle a gun from a suicidal woman. Cops say he is a killer and covered the body with trash bags.
- They Met Online And Were Supposed To Live Happily Ever After. Instead, Cops Found His Lover Buried In His Backyard.
Lay, the defense attorney argued in court, was fatally shot during the struggle that ensued. “Had John not acted when Donna pulled that gun, she would be the one sitting at that [defense] table,” Wilson said.
Commonwealth’s Attorney Ronnie Bowling countered during trial, “Donna’s body tells what happened” and Bowling placing her in the garbage can was the act “of a desperate man trying to hide his crimes.”
Meadows was awaiting sentencing in the Whitley County Detention Center.
Become a Front Page Detective
Sign up to receive breaking
Front Page Detectives
news and exclusive investigations.