MMA Fighter Taken Into Custody For Sexually Battering A Woman

A professional MMA fighter was taken into custody in Key West on May 18, 2026, after he was accused of sexually battering a woman in the street. The mixed martial arts fighter was allegedly wearing no clothes at that time, and he was stopped by the manager of a local strip club.

The manager took him to the officers in the area and reported the incident. The victim was later sent to a health clinic for a sexual-assault examination, according to the arrest report.

Logan Storley, 33, is originally from South Dakota and now lives in Deerfield Beach. According to his biography on PFL’s website, he won the Bellator welterweight title in May 2022 after defeating Michael “Venom” Page. Before jumping into a professional MMA career, he was a four-time NCAA Division-I All-American wrestler for the University of Minnesota.

Following his arrest, Storley was booked into Monroe County’s main jail on Stock Island. He is charged with one count of sexual battery. On May 19, he was released on a $50,000 bond.

According to his arrest report, Storley met his victim at the Bull and Whistle, which is a three-story bar on Duval Street. The encounter occurred around 3 a.m. According to the woman, he was trying to dance with her but “wanted to get away.”

The woman and her sister also saw other people in his group when he asked her to go to the third-floor bar called The Garden of Eden and “get naked.” According to the report, the woman said no, but eventually went to the upstairs bar.

There, Storley kept up with his attempt to dance with her, but she joined another woman “in an effort to avoid him.” The woman told investigators that she went back downstairs shortly and left the place without him noticing.

Storley allegedly followed her outside and forced her to go into an alley on Telegraph Lane. There, he took off his clothes and forced intercourse with the woman against her will. According to the arrest report, the incident was witnessed by several employees at a strip bar called Teasers.

Storley ran away after noticing the witnesses, leaving his clothes behind. However, the manager of the strip bar quickly apprehended him and handed him over to the police nearby.

Following his arrest, a PFL spokesperson said in an email statement that he was released from the league before committing the crime.